Motion for Directed Verdict

Michigan Post-Conviction Criminal Defense Attorney

Motion for Directed Verdict in Criminal Cases

In some criminal cases making a motion for directed verdict may be legally advantageous for the defendant.

A motion for directed verdict is a procedural device whereby the decision in a case is taken out of the hands of the jury by the judge. A verdict is generally directed in a jury trial only where there is no other possible conclusion because the prosecutor has not offered sufficient evidence to establish a prima facie (presumed to be true, unless proven otherwise) case. In other words, the prosecution has not met the criteria of showing a defendant's guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt."

  • A trial judge may direct the jury to acquit a defendant in a criminal case on the basis that the prosecution has not proved its case and the judge finds that there is insufficient evidence to convict.
  • A judge may not ask a jury to return a verdict of guilty because this would deprive the defendant of the constitutional right to a jury trial.

Federal and state Rules of Civil Procedure provide for directed jury motions, however, in a criminal action if an acquittal is directed in favor of a defendant, the jury is directed based upon Rules of Criminal Procedure.

Top

Client Reviews

★★★★★
Scott Grabel was kind enough to look into my situation and take his time to speak with me free of charge. Most attorneys will not do that. He gave me reassurance that I had nothing to worry about. If I am ever in need of an attorney in the future I will be calling Scott Grabel and will highly recommend him to anyone with a legal issue. G. K.
★★★★★
Great job Tim, Scott, Daniel very aggressive and knowledgeable They always call you back if you have questions even after hours the best outcome I could've hoped for thanks again R. E.
★★★★★
Great lawyer he went into court and ripped the girl trying to lie on me a new one. He fot me off on all charges and with out him i would be in prision. Thank you so much i will definitely keep your number and pass it on to any one in trouble and keep it for future incase i ever have to go back to court K. J.